Mark of the Fool

Chapter 650: Convergent Development

Chapter 650: Convergent Development

Grey.

The perfect word for the day.

Summers heat was waning.

Autumn rains were coming.

But this day didnt find Alex preparing for his new classes. He wasnt in the library or any study area around campus. Nor was he in the city working on his businesses.

He was in the office of his rather unconventional mana manipulation professor. Professor ValRok was one of those people who never seemed to change, except today his scales seemed a lot shinier. His excitable nature was on full display when he flung open his office door and found Alex standing before it.

Mr. Roth! he cried enthusiastically, licking his eyes in excitement. It has been some time since Ive seen you in my little office, or anywhere else, come to think of it.

Alex paused, more than a little startled by his enthusiasm. Erm, hello, professor. Im surprised youre so glad to see me.

Of course I am, come on in, my boy! ValRok beckoned him into the office.

A fire blazed in his hearth, filling the room with flickering light and a pleasant warmth on the late summer day.

Dozens of devices lined the spacebig, small and in-betweeneach designed for one purpose, training young wizards in mana manipulation. No two were alike; rows of glass tubes, brass spiders, silver hands, dried simian paws, and ropes knotted so intricately that they mystified the eye.

On this visit, ValRok had no students in his office to gleefully terrorise, so Alex found himself alone with the lizardfolk wizard.

Well, almost alone.

Ah, professor, whats that? Alex pointed to the instructors desk.

Upon it sat a large bowl filled with worms, beetles, wingless flies and more. Most of the insects were still, though some were still twitching, while others were actively trying to escape the container.

Insect salad. ValRok beamed, slapping his belly. Ive been trying to watch my paunch so I decided to do a little meal prepping on the weekends. Helps me build more discipline!

His tongue suddenly lashed out, striking a large beetle that had nearly made it across the rim of the bowl and dragging it into his mouth. Alex winced at the wet crunching sounds coming from between ValRoks teeth.

The lizardfolk wizard made a face. Yech, Ive got to tell you, Alex, I miss sauces already. A little jelly or aioli sauce makes the whole thing wake up. Oh, and some butter? MmmNo, no! ValRok suddenly shouted, chiding himself. Its a mind transformation, not a body transformation you greedy old reptile! Calm yourself! This is your new life!

I-is this a bad time, professor? Alex took a step back toward the door.

What? No, no! Couldnt be better. Itll be nice to chat with another mana manipulation prodigy while I have my lunch. Sit, sit. Have you eaten?

Yes! Alex said, putting more emphasis on the word than hed meant to. He took a seat in a comfortable looking chair in front of ValRoks desk.

Ah, well that's a pity. So, tell me, what can I do for you today? he asked. Are you looking for another mana regeneration technique? Remember, Ive already warned you about jumping ahead too quickly before you truly master your foundation. You wouldnt want to get messed up, would you?

Im not actually looking for a mana regeneration technique right nowthough Ill definitely come for a more advanced one when Im readyIm more looking forhow can I put thisgeneral mana manipulation knowledge?

Oh? You could just go to the library for general knowledge, ValRoks tongue whipped out, striking a glow worm and pulling it into his mouth. Mm, now thats better. Nice and juicy! You dont mind if I keep eating, right?

Oh, not at all, youre not bothering me, Alex lied. Okay, so general knowledge isnt right. Not exactly. Im more looking for an experts opinion on a certain text that I found.

Oh? the older wizard cocked his head.

Yeah, I came across this really old one, Alex chose his words carefully. But a lot of the mana manipulation notations seemed odd to me. I couldnt make much of them, so I thought Id come to you.

Alex pulled out a carefully copiedand very incompleteduplicate of Uldars notes, passing them to the mana manipulation professor. I was wondering if you could figure this out.

Hmmmm. The lizardfolks large reptilian eyes narrowed while his pupils expanded. Well, lets hope I dont disappoint you. Sometimes the mana manipulation techniques one finds in old tomesin dubious bazaars, for exampleoften amount to nothing. Either theyre fake, or simply dead end research sold in some wizards estate sale. As for thisI

His words trailed off.

His eyes began darting across the page.

Alex gripped the armrests of his chair.

Hed come to Professor ValRok hoping to get some answers from the wizard since he was an expert in mana manipulation with a mountain of experience and knowledge to draw from. Professor Jules had made detailed copies of Uldars notes for Alex, Watcher Hill and the Heroes, though the Heroes copy was kept at the Research Castle.

It wouldnt do to have the priests find this in your camp, Jules had said. Or the fae, for that matter.We should assume that this secret church and Aenflynns spies are everywhere, so Ill be taking measures to make sure the Castle is warded against any intrusions, but we still have to assume that any information that you take to your war-camp willbe compromised.

She had looked at Alex. I am trusting you with a copy, Mr. Roth, but be careful with it. I hope that the church and Aenflynns agents cant spy on us here in Generasi, but one never knows. Other than that, make sure any steps you take arent discovered, and do what you can to help solve this puzzle.

And so, Alex had come to ValRok, hoping that the professor could shed some light on their mystery.

Huh, ValRok mused. Where...did you get this?

A ruin in Thameland, Alex said, his words carefully chosen again. But thats not exactly for public knowledge.

Understood, understood, this will stay between us, but ValRok whistled. You have found something veryinteresting. This could be an incredible artefact.

Alex leaned forward. Is there some new technique in there? Something that could advance mana manipulation?

Hmmmm, possibly, ValRok said. I wont know for sure until I run a few experimentsbut I think you might have found an example of Convergent Development.

Whats that? Alex said excitedly.

Ah they didnt teach you that in magic lore, yeOh right, youre not even in your third year yet. Well, youll learn about it soon enough, but heres a little preview in the meantime. ValRok flipped through the papers, an absent note in his voice.

When one studies history, especially the history of technological or magical development, he began. It can be tempting to see it as a linear pattern of discovery that eventually culminates in modern knowledge. Millennia ago, mortals used sticks and stones to hunt beasts for meat. Then one day, someone develops bronze, which spreads, and soon, everyone is using bronze. We had no boats, then one day someone invents a boat, the knowledge spreads, then everyone has boats.

He looked at Alex. We have no mana manipulation techniques until someone invents them, then we have mana manipulation techniques. Your textbooks are filled with that way of viewing knowledge: they all start with: this particular dead wizard discovered this particular technique, and heres how their discoveriesblah, blah, blah.

Huh, they do word things that way, dont they? Alex mused.

And for good reason, Professor ValRok said. Listen, the act of crediting researchers, scholars or even artists is relatively new. In the past, no one credited inventors: we have no idea who discovered the original first-tier spell, who invented the wheel, or the first water pump. None. People did things to make their own lives easier, then others would copy them and that would be that. Now, we try to credit discoverers. There is, however, a problem with this.

ValRok put the notes down. It creates a false perception of history. Thats why historiographywhich is the study of historical accountsis so important. Did you ever hear of King Ivanuil in your studies?

Yeah, he was an ancient Irtyshenan king, Alex said. He was credited with being a grand sponsor of one of the first teams of court alchemists in history, and he pretty much popularised that practice among a lot more monarchs.

ValRok chuckled. And thats what your modern textbook says.

And what did they say before that? Alex raised his eyebrows.

Three centuries ago, the textbooks reported that King Ivaniul was an incredibly monstrous tyrant who kept a slave chamber of sorceresses and sorcerers, all of whom he had his way with, and who were made to work on alchemy for him and his glory until the day they dropped dead.

Ohoh! Alex clued in. I take it that the old textbooks used a false source, while the new ones are written using more reliable sources?

Exactly! ValRok exclaimed. The original accounts came from a trusted historian of the time, but! The lizardfolk raised a clawed finger. That trusted historian was paid by one of King Ivanuils political adversariesin whats now the core of the empireto make up an account that would historically embarrass the king. When this political opponent overthrew Ivanuil, this account was spread, which made it into older textbooks.

Right, right Alex said. And then another source was found?

Yes, there was an archeological discovery made two centuries agomemoirs from several of the surviving alchemists of Ivanuils courtwhich painted him as a kind and ambitious sponsor. Of course, more investigations were launched, including confirmations made through several long-lived individuals whod been present at courtat the time. And lo and behold! Something thatwe hopeis closer to the truth came out. So you see, history as we know it isnt a linear series of discovery and other events: its the chronicle of winners.

He picked up a wingless fly from the dish. If this fly could speak, what would it say about us? I imagine that to this lovely little morsel, I would be the cruel monster consuming it and all of its friends in sheer gluttony, while it was just a poor innocent creature. To me, its a mild pest and moderately bland source of food, and Im simply a hungry professor.

With a crunch, ValRok bit down on the fly, quickly swallowing it. And now? He tapped his belly. Now Im the only one who gets to tell the story! And forevermore, the fly is a mild pest and I am simply a hungry professor.

Alex thought about all the historical accounts of Thameland that the church had provided, and the number of omissions hed become aware of. Having that context in mind, ValRoks points made too much sense to the young wizard. So whats this have to do with those notes?

Well, the thing about discovery is that its not linear. It appears so when looking back, but its not. Take boats for instance. Its likely that boats werent invented by one person and then spread, its more likely that boats were invented all across the worldcompletely separatelyby different cultures. Someone from every civilization near water probably looked at the sea at some point and said, huh, how do I cross that?

So different people tried to solve the same problem and came up with similar answers, but only the most popular answers got recorded in textbooks?

Precisely! ValRok clapped. For simplicitys sake, you see, thats not really taught in first or second year, and only touched upon in fourth year. Students need to learn the foundations of modern wizardry before they begin exploring similar, often half-finished methods that were condemned to the graveyard of history.

And those mana manipulation techniques Alex squinted at the notes. You think theyre similar to some of our modern techniques, but approach problems slightly differently?

Exactly, Professor ValRok said. At least thats my theory from just a cursory examination: most of the symbols in this method seem to have been invented by the alchemist who crafted it, so I cant be one hundred percent certain. But thats what it looks like to me. The problem with techniques like these is that they use a slightly different methodology to accomplish similar goals, but modern alchemy is built on the methods that we already know well. Therefore, most advanced mana manipulation techniques would be largely incompatible with an old, dead-end theory such as this.

Alexs heartbeat suddenly sounded like a drum beating in his ears.

Kelda.

Professorwhat would happen if someone tried to, I dont know, recreate a magical artefact. But, they only had access to our modern alchemical techniques, while the magical artefact was created by an old convergently developed technique like in those notes?

ValRoks face turned grim. If there are enough incompatibilities between the two? The results could be catastrophic. Quite catastrophic.

Alex suddenly had a disturbing idea that could explain why Keldas soul was obliterated when shed tried to change her Mark.